“Is it me, or does ‘The Babysitter’ have two right hands?” moofthespoof wrote.
Indeed, the person in the photo appears to hold a bloody knife in their right hand—and a sandwich in their other right hand. Not convinced? Another Reddit user, 2tall4yoo, went through the trouble of recreating the photo using a knife and a piece of bread.
You can fact check the mistake yourself by holding an object (preferably not a knife) with your left hand behind your back. The placement of the thumbs in The Babysitter photo gives away the double right-handed mistake.
It appears Netflix has since replaced the cover photo for The Babysitter, which is too bad. We’ll take funny, innocent Photoshop fails over problematic ones any day.